Opinion by Jouslin Khairallah, Founder, Managing Director and Head of Litigation at KH Legal
A litigant may lodge a cassation petition on time and still face a question of admissibility if a fault in the court’s payment system prevents payment of the prescribed fee or lodging of the security deposit. In my view, a litigant who can prove that such a fault prevented timely compliance, despite acting diligently, should have a defined opportunity to pay once the service is restored.
The statutory rule for cassation
Article 179(1) of the Civil Procedure Code, promulgated by Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2022, requires the appellant to provide proof of full payment of the fee and lodging of the security deposit within three working days following the date of notice of the fee assessment. The petition is entered in the register once that requirement is met. Under Article 179(5), the court must declare a petition that was brought contrary to the prescribed requirements inadmissible of its own motion. Federal Decree-Law No. 22 of 2025 amended Articles 32, 164, 175 and 176. Article 179 remained unchanged by that amendment.
How the Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation reads the two deadlines
In its decision of 28 January 2026 on Civil Request No. 1 of 2026, the General Assembly of the Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation held that, where the petition was lodged on time, payment of the fee and lodging of the deposit may be made within the statutory cassation filing period even if the three working days have elapsed. The requirement can also be met within the three working days following notice even if the filing period has expired. The decision addresses the interaction between those two periods. Article 179 contains no express general rule suspending a payment deadline because of an outage.
Notice and payment failures raise different questions
If a technical fault prevents valid notice of the assessment, the question is whether the event that triggers the three-working-day period occurred. If valid notice was given but the link failed or the transaction could not be completed, the question is whether a fault in the court’s system caused the missed deadline. A failed link alone does not determine whether notice was valid. The applicable service rules and the court’s records matter in each case.
A documented outage should be linked to the particular case and payment attempt. Court service records, time-stamped error messages, transaction references and support requests can help establish when payment became unavailable, whether an authorised alternative was reasonably accessible and how promptly the litigant acted. These records also help distinguish a court-system fault from a problem with the payer’s own device, connection or means of payment.
The constitutional context
Article 41 of the UAE Constitution allows any person to complain to the competent authorities, including judicial authorities, about an infringement of the rights and freedoms protected under Part Three of the Constitution. That provision informs the case for proportionate procedural safeguards. The availability and admissibility of an appeal or cassation petition are governed by the applicable procedural law.
A permanent statutory safeguard
I propose that the court be empowered to grant relief where the petition was lodged on time and the litigant shows that an impediment beyond the control of the litigant and counsel prevented timely payment despite reasonable diligence and the absence of a reasonably accessible authorised alternative. The litigant should report the impediment promptly through an available authorised channel and provide the evidence reasonably obtainable. The court should determine a substantiated request before ruling on inadmissibility for non-payment.
How the proposed safeguard would work
A period that depends on notice would begin only upon valid notice. If the applicable payment period has already begun, it would be suspended for the time the proven impediment prevented payment. Once payment is possible and the litigant has been duly notified, the litigant would have the balance of the applicable period or three working days, whichever is longer. The fee and deposit would remain due. Compliance within that period would cure the delay caused by the proven impediment for admissibility purposes.
A temporary response to widespread outages
For a widespread or prolonged outage, the authority legally empowered to affect the applicable deadline could adopt a temporary measure identifying the services, periods and proceedings covered. The competent judicial authority should record the timing and scope of the disruption, publish restoration notices and make official confirmation available for use in proceedings, including where a fault affects an individual case.
Any transitional provision should identify the pending cases it covers and the relief available, subject to the applicable rules on finality and the statutory grounds for challenging judgments. Extending a similar safeguard to ordinary appeals or other stages would require reviewing the procedural and fee rules applicable to each court and stage.
A defined opportunity to pay after a proven outage would preserve collection of court fees and deposits while protecting litigants who acted diligently from losing review on a payment issue they could not remedy in time. These proposals would require adoption through the appropriate legal instrument.
This article sets out the author’s personal view and a proposal for legal reform. The proposals are not law in force. For advice on a specific matter, contact info@khlegal.ae · +971 4 427 0845.
Arabic version: اقرأ المقال بالعربية





